These days, there are many roofing materials available for homeowners to choose from. Out of these options, tiles and shingles are the two most common. Both materials offer excellent protection and can meet a variety of aesthetic or durability needs, but you will have to choose between one or the other. 

Overall, tiles and shingles have their respective unique benefits, especially for homes in Florida. Before making your decision with the best Central Florida roofer, take a look below at both materials to determine which is best for your needs.


Tiles are typically made from either concrete or clay and can come in a variety of different colors, cuts, and styles. Thanks to recent technology, tiles can fit any aesthetic: Mediterranean, Spanish, historical, contemporary, or even New England colonial. 

They are one of the longest-lasting roofing materials, making them an excellent choice for homeowners who don’t want to worry about a roof replacement anytime soon.


Traditional shingles are made from asphalt, but these days, shingles can be made from wood, fiberglass, and other materials. Despite first impressions, shingles are actually a very durable option and are common in homes in Florida. Depending on the chosen material, shingles can be made in different colors and fit different aesthetics easily.

Differences Between Tiles and Shingles

It’s no surprise that shingles and tiles are different, but looking closely at these differences can give you a better idea of which material will be best for your home. To compare each roofing material, take a look below.


In Florida, durability is a crucial factor to keep in mind. Although both materials do well in storms, shingles can come loose or need to be replaced after a hurricane. Tiles, however, can break easily when debris goes flying, and they’ll cost more to replace.


Based solely on initial costs, shingles are by far the cheapest option between the two. Even nice, aesthetic shingles will cost less than the cheapest tiles. Shingles are also cheaper to install, making them the budget-friendly option when comparing them with tiles.


Longevity is often associated with cost and quality, so it shouldn’t be too surprising to learn that tiles will last the longest. Although they are a bigger initial investment, tiles often last longer and will likely not need to be replaced within your lifetime. 

This eliminates the future costs of a roof replacement, which will be a significant expense. Shingles, although cheaper, will only last one to two decades, and after strong winds, they may need to be replaced or repaired.


Part of owning a home involves maintenance, and your roof is one of the most significant home maintenance expenses you’ll have. In Florida, where strong storms and hurricanes are common, maintenance concerns should be a significant factor of consideration.

Both tiles and shingles will need maintenance, but the costs will differ. Shingles may crack, curl, become loose, or lose granules with time and strong storms. Tiles may crack and break when hit by flying debris. While shingles will need more frequent repairs, these repairs are cheaper. Conversely, when tiles need repairs, the costs are higher and the work is more difficult.


Fortunately, both shingles and tiles have various options that allow you to meet different aesthetics. That being said, for some aesthetics, one option may be better than the other. For a Mediterranean-style home, for example, tiles tend to be a more logical choice, whereas a sleek, modern-style home may look great with asphalt or wood tiles. 


Both tiles and shingles make great roofing materials for homes in Florida. They each have their advantages and disadvantages, but both will protect your home when intense storms and hurricanes roll in. As such, it really depends on your own personal aesthetic goals and how much you’re willing to spend on the initial installation and future repairs. 

If you’re still unsure of which one to choose or have any further questions, don’t hesitate to call us, and we’ll be glad to give you some professional advice.